Monday, November 9, 2009

What About My Septic System?

We do a lot of work with rural home owners and see all kinds of different well water quality issues.  One thing most of these owners have in common is they have a septic system.  In our area, its common to have a septic field or a mound, but there are also a good number of surface-discharge or cesspool setups as well.  What these systems all have in common is the septic tank.  If you're not familiar with a septic tank, its usually just a two-chamber underground container that separates out the solids and liquids and gives bacteria a chance to do some breakdown of the materials prior to being discharged from the tank (or sucked out by a vac truck, if there actually is no discharge.)

Because these bacteria need to have the right conditions to live and enough time to do their job, its common to question whether it is appropriate to discharge water treatment equipment into septic systems.  There are concerns about salt-based systems killing bacteria or clogging up the pipes or even the soil in a septic field.  There are also concerns of "flooding" the septic tank with the water used in cleaning and regenerating water treatment equipment.  If too much water comes into the system too quickly, the bacteria will not have had a chance to work nor will separation into "sludge" (the solids,) and "scum" (the fats and greases that float to the top.) Without separation, the wrong things can go out to your field and cause massive problems - especially "biomat" - or an accumulation of a slimy layer in a septic field that clogs things up, eventually causing failure.  These are valid concerns, but that doesn't mean they are problems.

There is a lot of information available on this and there have been a LOT of studies performed.  The general consensus is: septic systems can be compatible with water treatment equipment.  Newer water treatment systems are more efficient than ever.  When they use less water to clean themselves, obviously that's less water going into the septic system.  Even the use of salt isn't a problem.  A recent study available from the Water Quality Association clearly talks to these points.

The end results actually show better operation of the septic system - including the field - when compared to not running the equipment.  Another benefit is the dramatic reduction of soaps, detergents and cleaning products that soft, iron-free water allows home owners to take advantage of.  The less these chemicals are dumped into our soils, the less impact on the environment.

To be sure, there are proponents of both sides, but it has clearly been shown that there are a lot of benefits to running rural water treatment equipment, and there is no reason that if done properly, the water treatment equipment should cause a concern for a septic system.

Resources:
  • For information on Pirana aerobic septic treatment and field remediation systems, please see the following LINK.
  • For information on WaterMax the most-efficient, "septic friendly" water softening and treatment systems available, please click HERE.
  • For a FREE, useful PDF on this topic from the Water Quality Research Council:
    http://www.wqa.org/pdf/Consumer%20Briefs/cSoftprobseptic.pdf
  • For a free copy of a paper from NOWRA (National On-site Wastewater Recycling  Association) the organization representing the septic treatment industry, please download the PDF HERE.

Thursday, November 5, 2009

Reverse Osmosis - Fact vs Fiction, Volume 4

Today is the last installment in the "Fact vs Fiction" or "Myth Buster" series...

Myth #7: Reverse Osmosis Systems are Prohibitively Expensive

Myth Busted
: Costs are always more for better quality, better performing systems. There are budget RO systems that start around $500 (or less, depending upon where you live) and go up from there. What price do you put on health??? Sure you can cheap out, but you're simply increasing the chemicals and contaminants you allow into your drinking water, as well as increasing your operating and maintenance costs... Better systems also tend to have much longer, more-comprehensive warranties.  They are often better-tested at the factory and have a lower failure rate and less chance of a problem at the time of installation.

Most dealers, like ourselves, offer different systems at different price points. Depending upon the need and budget of families, we can tailor a system that will be just right. Just bear in mind, this is kind of like insulation - you either buy it up-front, or you pay more over time to operate your system. The more-efficient systems use less water (saving money if you're on a meter, saving your septic field if you're not) and because they process less water to achieve the same production volume, they can run their filters for longer -often only requiring filter changes every year.

Inexpensive systems, due to their inefficiency, require a lot more source water to create the same volume of product water of a high-efficiency system.  Because of this, their filters expire faster and can require changing as often as every 3 months. Pay now or pay later... The choice is yours!

To put it in perspective, compare a reverse osmosis system, which can be roughly described as a "washing machine for your water" to an actual washing machine.  There are two types of washing machines currently on the market - standard "top loaders" and the new High Efficiency (or "HE") machines which are "front loaders."  The newer, more efficient HE machines cost more, but they also use less water to do the job. 

Do top loaders "waste" water?  I don't know - but they definitely USE more water to accomplish the same job.  Reverse osmosis is the same way - there are "standard" units and "high efficiency" units.  The high efficiency models cost more up front, but have lower operating costs, require fewer filter changes, have increased pressure and use less water to operate.  They are more efficient, greener systems.  Pay now, or pay later (and continuously while you operate the system.)

Myth #8: RO Creates Acidic Water, and Acidity Causes Cancer

Myth Busted:
This one drives me nuts - it is a blatant ploy by marketing departments to scare people into buying their high-priced ionizers or alkalinizers... (For the record, I am NOT a doctor and will NOT touch the acidity - cancer link.  It may very well be true that acidic cells are more prone to cancer, or are consistent with those cells in a cancerous state.  

I believe it is a LEAP to go from that potential fact to attempt to link it to the pH of water you drink having the effect of raising the pH of the body and thereby putting it in a state that is more prone to cancer.  I am not qualified to comment on that, HOWEVER I can talk about water and am qualified to discuss that aspect of this myth AND comment on what happens in the body when you digest this alkaline water.)

The only way the RO process can acidify the water is if it is removing something like soda ash which was added to raise the pH. Even then, and I HAVE tested this on this type of water, the change in pH is negligible - you need a very sensitive meter to even detect the change. When I test "raw tap water" and RO processed water from the same source, right beside each other, the difference in pH is around 0.1.  (In our area, that's the difference between tap water being 7.78 and RO water being 7.6 pH.)  It is certainly not "acidic" water (acidic is defined as having a pH lower than 7.) I've seen some sales literature showing RO water as having a pH around 3.0 -strongly acidic. This is just patently false.  I'm surprised these companies are not getting sued.

Even if it were a good idea to drink this alkaline water, let's take this a step further.  Follow this process... You drink water, it goes past your mouth and heads where? To your stomach.

Your stomach's pH is around 2.0 -it contains hydrochloric acid, a necessary substance for digestion. Adding water of higher pH only serves to raise the pH of your stomach. I've seen product literature stating that your stomach's pH is only that low when you're eating, the rest of the time it is closer to neutral - around 7.0. Really??? Ask your doctor!  (Or if this is easier, check with Google!)

If you want to spend $3000 or more on a "water alkalinizer" go fill your boots. What you end up with is expensive water that has been treated with a carbon filtration unit roughly equivalent to one single stage of a multi stage RO unit.  By design, your stomach is supposed to be acidic; that's where digestion starts.  Raising the pH in your stomach is NOT a good idea.  This is pure snake oil!

(in terms of complete disclosure, one of Douglas Environmental Solutions suppliers DOES offer these alkaline water systems for sale.  I have seen their specs and I have seen their marketing literature - it is truly misleading.  I'm surprised at this ploy by an otherwise reputable company.  Although it technically is something we can make available through this one supplier, we do NOT intend to market the product nor offer it to our clients.)

Wednesday, November 4, 2009

Reverse Osmosis - Fact vs Fiction, Volume 3

Today's installment in this series addresses two concerns I've seen several times, mostly on "articles" which appear to be nothing more than sales letters for some other kind of water treatment system... One has to do with cleaning the system, which is an integral part of almost any "cartridge in sump" filtration setup.

The only kind of filtration appliance that doesn't need some kind of periodic cleaning and sanitizing is one where the entire assembly (basically everything except the plumbing itself) gets changed out at filter change time.  These systems can be convenient, but filter changes are more expensive and involve a lot of waste - extra plastic housings which are thrown out each filter change, instead of just the spent filter cartridges themselves.  Definitely a trade off in these days where we want to be as GREEN as possible.

Myth #5: When you Sanitize a Reverse Osmosis (RO) System, Chlorine Reacts with Organics to Create Disinfection Byproducts.

Myth Busted:
I think they're really lost in the woods here... The chlorine is rinsed away after the sanitization and BEFORE the RO system is brought back online. Even if chlorine was left in the system at the time the system was re-activated, it is designed specifically to remove chlorine AND disinfection byproducts. I mean - that is the point of an RO system. To say it all the sudden cannot do it because you're cleaning it makes no sense. Again - hogwash...

Myth #6: RO is a Slow Process and Cannot Produce Enough Water for My Family

Myth Busted:
RO does take time to process water, but that's why there's a storage tank! RO systems can be specified with membranes that produce anywhere from around 12 gallons per day, up to 50 gallons per day for standard residential use. There are membrane options up to 250 gallons per day that will still fit and work with a standard residential RO system.

Exactly how much water are you planning on using? Even the slowest system still can produce the equivalent of two 5-gallon jugs of water a day. Most residential systems ship with either a 24 or 50 gallon per day membrane. That is plenty for almost any family. I've even deployed a system like this for commercial use with absolutely no problems. Larger storage tanks are also available. Most come with 3-4 gallon capacity, but there's really no limit to tank size, other than whatever space limitations you may have.

HINT: Mount the RO in the basement and most-often your size restrictions go away completely since most basements aren't quite as tight on space as the areas underneath kitchen sinks (but again, most residences need no more capacity than a standard 3 gallon tank, which takes between 1 and 3 hours to completely refill from empty.)  This not only allows you to use a bigger tank, it also allows you to keep the space under the sink for garbage cans, recycling/composting bins and cleaning products.  

-NOTE: this should only be done if the RO system is ultra-efficient and doesn't lose a lot of water pressure compared to the home's normal water supply.  Some systems lose as much as one third of the home's pressure by the time the water is stored in the tank.  

If the house has 60 PSI water and the tank only has 40 PSI, by the time you run a length of plumbing all the way from the basement up to the kitchen or main floor dispenser, you could be down to 30 PSI or less - definitely could result in slow water delivery and low pressure at the faucet...  (This is one reason I especially like the Hague H3500 RO system with the non-electric permeate pump built right in - this keeps pressure at the optimal setting, makes water faster and increases the amount of contaminants removed from the water.)

This may not be possible with some 'bargain brand' RO systems. 



Tuesday, November 3, 2009

Reverse Osmosis - Fact vs Fiction, Volume 2


Back again today with the next installment of our myth-busting series on reverse osmosis systems.  There's a lot of bunk out there, and we're going to wade through it point by point.  As a consumer, you have a right to make an informed decision, not just having to buy-in based on some slick sales literature.  So here are the facts versus the fiction of what's out there...  Remember, if they need to back up their documentation with words like, "technically speaking...." then your guard should be up.  So here's round two:

Myth #3: RO Wastes a LOT Of Water

Myth Busted:
RO is just like a washing machine for your water. Does your dishwasher "waste" water? How about your washing machine? No - it simply uses water to clean things. In this case, an RO system uses water to produce clean water, rinsing impurities down the drain just like soil on clothes and remnants of food from your plates. Because it is able to rinse away impurities instead of having to trap them in filters, a typical RO system's filters last a LOT longer! Think about it. A filter can only hold so much. Once it is full of contaminants, it needs to be discarded. If you were able to design a filter that trapped the contaminants RO systems separate from water and rinse away, you'd need to not only buy additional filters, but also change them more often.  

Myth #4: RO Units are Not Customizable

Myth Busted:
Any filter you can add into one of the often-recommended "multi-stage filtration units" can be added into an RO system. As long as the chlorine (and iron, if you're on a well) is removed prior to the membrane, you can use any combination of filters you want. An RO is basically the same as the multi-stage system several manufacturer's seem to recommend, but with the addition of a reverse osmosis membrane. To suggest this is somehow less flexible is hogwash...

...to be continued!

Monday, November 2, 2009

Reverse Osmosis - Fact vs Fiction


Today we're going to start debunking some of the urban legends out there surrounding reverse osmosis (RO.) RO was invented years ago as a way to desalinate water for the US Navy submarines. Its a stable technology that has had numerous advancements in terms of efficiency and performance over its life span. There is a lot of confusion over RO technology out there - claims that it can't do this, shouldn't do that, requires something else, etc.

I have done a lot of research not only on water purification, but also on water and its effect on health. There are a lot of people shucking half-truths out there, so let's get started....

Myth #1: Reverse Osmosis is inferior to Carbon Filtration at Chemical Removal


Myth Busted: RO is NEVER (NEVER EVER EVER) used with a membrane alone. They always have PRE and POST filters to treat the water before and after the membrane (always.) -Anything an under-counter filtration system can remove, an RO SYSTEM can remove. To say the membrane can't remove certain chemicals is true, but to say an RO SYSTEM can't remove them is a flat out lie...

Myth #2: RO Removes Calcium and Vital Minerals from the Water

Myth Busted: There's not a shred of medical evidence that shows your body can process inorganic (or non-chelated) minerals such as calcium. These minerals are in the same form as limestone rock, or chalk.

You need calcium in your diet, but it needs to be organic calcium - bonded with amino acids (the process that happens in plants like broccoli, and inside the 9 stomachs of cows that makes the calcium bioavailable.) No doctor would recommend eating chalk or sucking on rocks to supplement the calcium in your diet.

Furthermore, the minute amount of calcium your body could absorb (even if it were possible) is vastly outweighed by the chemicals and disinfection byproducts/trihalomethanes the RO process removes from the water. The argument that these minerals are essential is akin to suggesting its ok to eat an entire bag of unlabelled pills because you're sure there are a few vitamin C's in there... No-one has any idea what chemicals are in the water - digesting them all just to get a few bits of calcium is ridiculous. Take supplements, eat green veggies, cheese or yogurt - you'll get what you need without the chemicals (assuming its organic, that is...)

...to be continued! 

In the meantime, if you have any concerns about RO or other water quality concerns, visit us at www.douglasenviro.ca and submit your question via the "Ask The Expert" section at the bottom of the Contact Us form, or email directly at info@douglasenviro.ca!

Saturday, October 31, 2009

What's this Build Up??


I visited with a gentleman yesterday in Sherwood Park. He called me over out of frustration. He's lived in his home for 20 years and has constantly been battling scale build-up, especially in recent years. Edmonton's water (Sherwood Park gets its municipal water from Edmonton) used to be quite a bit softer, but in the 1990's, that changed and the water is, according to the Water Quality Association, hard. But what does that mean???

Hardness in this area is mostly dissolved limestone rock. Water, a "universal solvent," picks up a bit of everything it comes in contact with. As it runs over the rocks in mountains and all the way here via the North Saskatchewan river, it picks up limestone and dissolves it in the form of "water hardness." Hardness is measured in "Grains Per Gallon" -an old measurement of weight, but the one still used today in industry. 7000 grains is one pound, and by comparison, an aspirin tablet is about 5 grains.

Testing his water, we found the hardness in his home to be 10 grains per gallon, or for every gallon of water going through the home, about two aspirin tablets worth of dissolved limestone rock. With two people in the home, and an average of 150 gallons per day of water being used, that's about 1/5th of a pound of rock going through the home's water system every single day. (That's more than 75 pounds a year!!!)

Dissolved calcium is a bit of a different creature - unlike most things dissolved in water, it actually is LESS soluble with increased temperature. That means that when water is heated, it causes even more of the dissolved rock to come out of the water both coating anything it comes in contact with, and building up in the bottom of things.

If you've ever had to change your hot water tank, you know what I'm talking about - one small person can carry in and install a new hot water tank, but because of the several pounds of rock that builds up in the bottom of a "used" hot water tank, it takes two grown men and usually a cart to remove it...

Anyway, his staining and damage from hard water was quite extensive. His humidifier, which had just been cleaned recently, was already caked with white scale. The floor under his humidifier (beside the furnace) also had white rock formations on it, as did the inside of the furnace where the water connection was made.

He also pulled out the aerators on his faucets and showed me the little white pebbles and chips that were getting caught there. This is another area where hard water buildup can accumulate - not just as the white pearly/seashell kind of effect you see around most sinks and faucets. These are all evidence of hard water damage. He showed me how his faucet would sputter and spurt as the water fought to get through the clogged up system.

The prognosis here was quite simple, we discussed two options to fix this issue. The Watermax City Water Conditioner, as well as the "Puratech" system - basically the Watermax's little brother. Both will do an excellent job and remove all the hardness from the water going through all the plumbing in the home - this will eliminate the cause of the buildup my client was concerned about. The Watermax goes a step further and removes all the chlorine and disinfection byproducts that come from the chlorination of water. Health Canada has shown this to be cancer causing at certain exposure levels. Unfortunately, most municipalities don't test for these levels, and those that do test them, NEVER publish them.

In this case, the gentleman's concerns were strictly over maintenance, not specifically over health, so we decided on the Puratech system which will solve the problem and do it using the least amount of salt and water possible. PROBLEM SOLVED!

Thursday, October 29, 2009

My Well Water is Bad & the Well is Going Dry - Help!


I received a call last week from a person that was in a panic about their well water. They have a lot of hardness in the water, but have another problem - many wells in the area are going dry. They've noticed that running water constantly for an hour or more depletes the well and are concerned about the trend in the area.

The water is so hard, they have to replace their fixtures about every two years. They have made arrangements for a trickle system to be installed (this is a set up where city water from a nearby municipality is delivered at low pressure and flow rate into an atmospheric holding tank at the property, from which the water is then pressurized and delivered much the way someone with a cistern's is.) The problem is, that water is at least a year away, and when it comes, it still will be hard water, and will have the added problem of chlorine. What to do, what to do???

We visted the gentleman on Tuesday afternoon and tested the water. Sure enough - its very hard water. There wasn't much for iron or other contaminants, but there was a fair amount of sediment coming thru. This made the diagnosis rather simple - a Hague Watermax water conditioner.

The system recommended for this gentleman will filter out sediment down to 20 microns (smaller than the eye can see) for the whole home using a built-in "Ultra-Fil" module - whole-house dirt and sediment filter that never needs replacement filters or maintenance; it cleans itself automatically each time the conditioner regenerates - slick, eh?

Using Hague's patented "Zero Soft" approach, all hardness will be completely removed by the fine mesh resin, and "Bacteriostat" inhibits growth in the resin bed, keeping the Watermax fresh and clean for the life of the appliance.

Next year, when they migrate from their well water to a city water supply, "Chlorostat" is added to completely remove the clorine, and activated coconut shell carbon will be installed into the empty media chamber to remove organics and disinfection byproducts - an unwanted result of the chlorination system that has been linked to cancer.

The nice thing about working with the Hague line-up is the flexibility. With this system, when water conditions or even water supplies change, there's a good change Watermax can change with you. Two days after the initial visit, he had spoken with the other water companies in the area (I was the first one to come out) and liked what he saw with Hague. We're welcoming him to the Hague family next Friday when his system is going in!